Skip to main content

Fighting Drought with Fire: A Comparison of Burned and Unburned Forests in Drought-Impacted Areas of the Southwest

Fighting Drought with Fire: Can Managers Increase Forest Resistance to Drought using Prescribed Fire?
Principal Investigator
Phillip van Mantgem

Dates

Start Date
2015-08-28
End Date
2018-02-28
Release Date
2015

Summary

Drought is one of the biggest threats facing our forests today. In the western U.S., severe drought and rising temperatures have caused increased tree mortality and complete forest diebacks. Forests are changing rapidly, and while land managers are working to develop long-term climate change adaptation plans, they require tools that can enhance forest resistance to drought now. To address this immediate need, researchers are examining whether a common forest management tool, prescribed fire, can be implemented to help forests better survive drought. Prescribed fire is commonly used in the western U.S. to remove potential wildfire fuel, such as small trees and shrubs. It is also thought that this act of selectively removing some trees [...]

Child Items (4)

Contacts

Attached Files

Click on title to download individual files attached to this item.

Fire_MaryCernicek_MPD.jpg
“Wildfire - Credit: Mary Cernicek”
thumbnail 242.96 KB image/jpeg

Purpose

Prescribed fire is a primary tool used to restore southwestern forests following more than a century of fire exclusion. Prescribed fire reduces fire risk partly by removing small trees, shrubs, and surface litter; it is also assumed that following fire there is less competition among remaining trees so that they are more resistant (more likely to survive) in the face of additional stressors, such as drought. Yet this proposition remains untested, so that managers do not have the basic information they need for to evaluate whether prescribed fire actually achieves this objective. In the face of ongoing climatic changes, is a dollar best spent on increasing forest resistance using prescribed fire, or is it best spent on other climate change adaptation needs? The severe and on-going drought across much of the southwestern United States provides a remarkable natural experiment to test whether prescribed fire helps trees survive stressful conditions. If current practices for modifying forest conditions through fire are found to increase drought resistance, our project could help forest managers apply these methods across western forests more broadly. The results of this study may change management policy to maximize resource benefit from fire. Our specific questions are as follows. (1) Does prescribed fire actually increase forest resistance to drought, and if so, by how much? (2) If so, does the strength of that resistance depend on time since fire? For example, is drought resistance initially low following a burn, but increasing in subsequent years and decades? (3) Do the benefits of prescribed fire, with regard to resistance, vary among tree species and size classes? In particular, is the resistance of large trees - which sequester the most carbon and are critical to wildlife - enhanced by prescribed burns? Results will help land managers make informed decisions on how to allocate their limited climate-change adaptation funds.

Project Extension

parts
typeTechnical Summary
valueObjectives/Justification: Using the severe drought in the southwestern U.S. as a natural experiment we will leverage several ongoing projects to combine direct measurements of tree mortality with tree-ring indices of tree health, providing a first large-scale quantification of the efficacy of a key management tool – prescribed fire – to increase forest resistance to severe drought (addressing SWCSC Research FY15 Priority 2). Background: Otherwise undisturbed forests of the western U.S. are experiencing increasing tree mortality and complete diebacks linked to drought and rising temperatures. Land managers, as they work to develop robust climate change adaptation strategies, are keen to buy time by enhancing forest resistance (sensu Walker et al. 2004) to such abrupt, severe, and widespread changes. Reductions in tree density following prescribed fire have been widely presumed to increase resistance to drought. Yet this proposition has remained untested until now, meaning land managers do not have the basic information they need for critical cost-benefit analyses. Procedures/Methods: We will examine the primary measure of forest resistance, tree survivorship, across hundreds of existing burned and unburned forest monitoring plots in which the fates of individual trees of all species and sizes have been tracked for decades. We will compare proportions of trees surviving the drought in the burned vs. unburned plots, quantifying the effects of time since fire and differences among species and size classes. We have already leveraged USGS and NPS funds to re-read many of these plots – mostly in California; we will seek SWCSC funds to re-read other plots in Arizona, New Mexico and Utah. Expected Products and Information/Technology Transfer: We will use LCC communication pathways (e.g., webinars) and on-site visits to communicate our findings to managers and the public. We will also produce peer-reviewed journal articles, with associated web-based outreach materials aimed at managers. We will make our data “open access” following publication to encourage further work on this topic. Personnel/Cooperators/Partners: Our research team has extensive publication records in top journals in the fields of climate change impacts, fire science, forest ecology and tree-ring analysis. Much of our work has focused on understanding the patterns and processes of tree mortality in relation to disturbance and climate variability.
projectStatusCompleted

Budget Extension

annualBudgets
year2015
totalFunds146620.0
totalFunds146620.0

Wildfire - Credit: Mary Cernicek
Wildfire - Credit: Mary Cernicek

Map

Spatial Services

ScienceBase WMS

Communities

  • National and Regional Climate Adaptation Science Centers
  • Southwest CASC
  • USGS Western Ecological Research Center

Associated Items

Tags

Provenance

Additional Information

Identifiers

Type Scheme Key
RegistrationUUID NCCWSC 189525fc-2186-4a7a-b2d2-95e3b46cc00e
StampID NCCWSC SW14-VP0134

Item Actions

View Item as ...

Save Item as ...

View Item...